Misuse of Law 104 leave - Ponzi Investigazioni

Ponzi Investigazioni > Corporate investigations > Misuse of Law 104 leave

Law 104 abuse: investigations to ascertain improper use of leave permits

Law 104/1992 grants employees three days of paid monthly leave to care for family members with severe disabilities. This is a fundamental protection, but one that is sometimes misused. The abuse of Law 104 leave is not just a contractual violation: according to the Supreme Court, it also constitutes fraud against INPS, which pays the salary for the absence days. Ponzi Intelligence gathers objective, documented evidence in full compliance with the law, enabling the company to protect itself.

Regulatory context

Article 33 of Law 104/1992 provides that leave must be used for the care of the disabled family member. The Supreme Court has established important principles over time: even a single episode of abuse can justify dismissal for just cause (Cass. no. 17102/2021); care need not be continuous but must be ‘adequate’ (Cass. no. 5906/2025); using leave for activities entirely unrelated to care violates the principles of good faith (Cass. no. 6468/2024, no. 11999/2024, no. 13274/2024). However, brief personal breaks (such as shopping) do not automatically constitute abuse (Cass. no. 24130/2024). The employer may legitimately engage a private investigation agency to carry out checks even outside working hours (Cass. no. 4984/2014).

Phase 1:Planning: We agree with the company on the leave days to monitor and the context (address of the disabled relative, schedules, known habits).Pianificazione: Definiamo con l'azienda le giornate di permesso da monitorare e il contesto (indirizzo del familiare disabile, orari, abitudini note).
Phase 2:Direct observation: Our operatives conduct discreet surveillance throughout the leave day, documenting the subject's movements and activities.
Phase 3:Photo and video documentation: Every observed activity is documented with georeferenced, chronologically organised photographic and video material.
Phase 4:Chronological analysis: We reconstruct a detailed timeline of the day, highlighting the time devoted to care versus time spent on personal activities.
Phase 5:Investigative report: We deliver a detailed report with chronology, evidence and overall assessment, ready for use in disciplinary or legal proceedings.

SCENARIO 1

The employee running the family business
A logistics company suspects that a warehouse worker uses his Law 104 leave to work in his wife's restaurant. Ponzi documents that on leave days the employee never visits his disabled parent's home but spends the entire day at the restaurant, performing kitchen and table service duties. The photographic timeline covers three consecutive days.

SCENARIO 2

The 'sports' leave
An insurance company clerk regularly takes Law 104 leave on Fridays. The company notices that the following Monday he posts social media photos of amateur sporting competitions in locations far from his family member's residence. Ponzi verifies and documents that during leave days the employee participates in cycling races, without ever visiting the disabled relative.

SCENARIO 3

Systematic partial abuse
A bank manager uses Law 104 leave to care for his elderly mother. Ponzi ascertains that actual care is limited to 40 minutes in the morning, after which the employee spends the rest of the day at a construction site where he is renovating a second property. The systematic nature of the behaviour across multiple days strengthens the evidentiary framework.

The pluses of the service

Professional and discreet surveillance

Georeferenced photo/video documentation

Detailed daily chronological timeline

Regulatory compliance and respect for dignity

What's included in the service

What's includeddirect observation during leave days, georeferenced photo/video documentation, detailed chronological timeline, certified investigative report.

What's NOT included:judgement on disciplinary severity (employer and legal counsel's competence), access to medical data of the disabled relative, assessment of the degree of disability.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a company have an employee checked who uses Law 104 leave?

Yes. The Supreme Court (no. 4984/2014) confirmed the legitimacy of checks via private investigators even outside working hours. The employer has the right to verify that leave is used for the care of the disabled family member and not for unrelated personal purposes.

Is a single episode of abuse enough for dismissal?

Yes, according to the Supreme Court (no. 17102/2021). Even a single episode of abuse of Law 104 leave can justify dismissal for just cause, as it irreparably breaches the trust relationship with the employer and the principles of good faith.

What is the difference between legitimate use and abuse of Law 104 leave?

Care need not be continuous throughout the day but must be ‘adequate’ (Cass. 2025). Brief personal breaks (shopping, having a coffee) are tolerable if care remains the main activity. Abuse occurs when leave is used for activities entirely unrelated to care: work, sport, travel, extended leisure.

Is abuse of Law 104 leave also a criminal offence?

Yes. The Supreme Court has clarified that abuse of Law 104 leave constitutes fraud against INPS, since leave days are paid by the social security institution. It is a criminal offence prosecutable ex officio (aggravated fraud against a public body, Art. 640 Criminal Code), so no company report is necessary.

How long does an investigation into Law 104 leave abuse take?

Generally at least 2-3 leave days are monitored to build a meaningful evidentiary framework. The entire process, from engagement to report, typically takes 2-4 weeks. Ponzi defines the timeline in the initial operational plan.

Request a consultation