Non-compete agreement breach - Ponzi Investigazioni

Ponzi Investigazioni > Corporate investigations > Non-compete agreement breach

Non-compete agreement breach: verification and evidence for corporate protection

The non-compete agreement (Art. 2125 Civil Code) is a contractual instrument through which the employer restricts the former employee’s professional activity after termination, in exchange for financial compensation. When this agreement is breached, the company suffers direct damage and has the right to take legal action. But to do so, concrete evidence is needed. Ponzi Intelligence verifies whether former employees or associates are breaching their commitments, providing solid, court-usable documentary evidence.

Regulatory context

Article 2125 of the Civil Code governs non-compete agreements in employment relationships. To be valid, the agreement must meet four cumulative requirements: written form, adequate compensation for the worker (not symbolic or disproportionate), and determined limits of subject matter, time and territory. Maximum duration is 5 years for executives and 3 years for others. The Supreme Court (no. 11766/2025) reiterated that compensation must be proportionate to the sacrifice required. Breach may result in return of compensation already received, payment of a penalty (if stipulated) and damages (Art. 1218 Civil Code). Article 2596 Civil Code governs contractual competition limits in non-employment relationships.

Phase 1: Contractual analysis: We examine the non-compete agreement to verify its formal and substantive validity and define the scope of prohibited activities.
Phase 2:Preliminary research: We check open sources and databases for whether the former employee has started new activities, taken positions with competitors or formed companies with overlapping corporate purposes.
Phase 3:Direct observation: We monitor the subject's professional activities to document conduct incompatible with the agreement.
Phase 4:Documentary evidence gathering: We acquire evidence on company registry entries, online professional profiles, shareholdings, trade fair attendance, contacts with the former employer's clients.
Phase 5:Report and legal support: We produce a complete evidentiary file organised for contractual breach proceedings.

SCENARIO 1

The executive founding a mirror company
The technical director of an industrial automation company, bound by a three-year non-compete agreement, is formally unemployed. Ponzi discovers that the former executive has established a limited company in his wife's name, headquartered in the same industrial district with an identical corporate purpose, of which he is effectively the covert administrator. The company has already acquired three of the former employer's long-standing clients.

SCENARIO 2

The disguised transfer via a consultancy firm
A former key account manager at an IT services company gets hired as a 'strategic consultant' by a generic consultancy firm but actually works exclusively for a direct competitor, managing the same client portfolio he previously handled. Ponzi documents the true nature of the assignment and the exclusivity relationship.

SCENARIO 3

The former employee operating from abroad
A software engineer at a fintech company, bound by a non-compete agreement with European scope, has reportedly relocated to London. Ponzi verifies that the former employee works as a freelancer for a competing platform registered in the UK, serving Italian clients and using skills and contacts developed at the previous company.

The pluses of the service

Open source and digital research

Observation during absences

Company registry and corporate checks

Report for disciplinary action

What's included in the service

What's includedcontractual analysis of the agreement, database and open source research, company registry and corporate verification, direct observation, certified evidentiary report.

What's NOT included:legal opinion on the agreement's validity (lawyer's competence), direct legal proceedings.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a non-compete agreement?

It is a contractual arrangement (Art. 2125 Civil Code) whereby the employer restricts the former employee’s professional activity after termination, in exchange for financial compensation. To be valid it must be in writing, with adequate compensation and determined limits of subject matter, time (max 3 years, 5 for executives) and territory.

How is breach of the agreement proven?

Ponzi conducts checks on company registry entries, professional profiles, shareholdings and the former employee’s observable activities. Evidence collected documents whether the subject is performing activities prohibited by the agreement, producing an evidentiary file for contractual breach proceedings.

What risks does someone face for breaching a non-compete agreement?

Consequences may include return of compensation received, payment of the contractual penalty (if stipulated) and compensation for the damage actually suffered by the employer. In some cases, the court may also issue an injunction prohibiting continuation of the competing activity.

Request a consultation